Eden Rock vs Hotel Le Toiny: Which to Book

The short answer

Same island. Different pace.

Both are small, top St Barths hotels. Eden Rock sits on its rock in the middle of Baie de Saint-Jean, two miles from the airport. Le Toiny is 22 villa suites, each with a heated pool, in 42 acres on the undeveloped southeastern coast.

Eden Rock – St Barths

Rooms37 rooms, suites and villas; Rock Suites on the rock, Beach Rooms on the sand, three private villas

SettingOn the rock in Baie de Saint-Jean, about two miles from the airport

Best forCouples who want the bay and the scene, and families who want a villa with hotel service

See the hotel →

Hotel Le Toiny

Rooms22 villa suites over 1,500 sq ft, each with a terrace and heated pool; La Villa (2 bedrooms) and Villa Nureyev (4 bedrooms)

Setting42 acres of tropical garden on the southeastern coast, 15 minutes from the airport

Best forCouples who want privacy, and families who want a two- or four-bedroom villa with its own pool

See the hotel →

Eden Rock St Barths

The rock in Saint-Jean.

Thirty-seven rooms, suites and villas on the rock in Baie de Saint-Jean, founded in the 1950s and an Oetker Collection hotel today. The Rock Rooms, Rock Suites and Legacy Suites sit on the rock; Beach Rooms and the Heavenly Beach House are on the sand.

For a family, Villas Nina, Rockstar and Frangipani are the private houses, and Eden Rock Villa Rental manages more than 220 villas across the island with hotel service.

See Eden Rock – St Barths →

Hotel Le Toiny

A villa suite and a pool.

Twenty-two ocean-view villa suites, each a free-standing cottage over 1,500 square feet with a private terrace and heated pool. They sit in 42 acres of tropical garden above the bay of Toiny.

Below is the Le Toiny Beach Club, with full beach service and a shuttle from the suites. For a family, La Villa has two bedrooms and Villa Nureyev has four.

See Hotel Le Toiny →

What they share

Small, private, close to the airport.

Both are small hotels near the airport, both have private villas for a family, and both include daily breakfast for two per bedroom when you book with us.

Booked through us

Same rate. More included.

You pay the hotel’s own rate. At Eden Rock we add an upgrade when available, daily breakfast for up to two per bedroom, roundtrip private airport transfers, an Eden Rock beach set and early check-in or late check-out.

At Le Toiny: an upgrade when available, daily full breakfast for two per bedroom, a $100 food and beverage credit and early check-in or late check-out. Airport transfers there are complimentary too.

Check my dates →

Our pick

Which one we’d book.

For couples who want the bay and the restaurants: Eden Rock. A Rock Suite over Baie de Saint-Jean, with transfers included.

For privacy and a pool of your own: Le Toiny. A villa suite with a heated pool, or Villa Nureyev with four bedrooms for the whole family.

Tell us who’s coming and we’ll tell you which rooms are worth it.

Check my dates

Questions, answered.

Which is better for a multi-generation group or older kids?

Both have room for a family. Le Toiny’s Villa Nureyev has four bedrooms and La Villa has two, each with its own pool. Eden Rock has Villas Nina, Rockstar and Frangipani, and manages more than 220 villas across the island with hotel service.

Which is better for couples?

Both. Eden Rock’s Rock Suites sit on the rock over Baie de Saint-Jean. Le Toiny’s villa suites are each over 1,500 square feet with a private terrace and heated pool.

How do they differ?

Eden Rock is 37 rooms on Baie de Saint-Jean, about two miles from the airport. Le Toiny is 22 villa suites in 42 acres on the southeastern coast, 15 minutes from the airport, with a beach club below.

Is the rate the same as booking direct?

Yes. The nightly rate is the hotel’s own best available rate. Booked through us, it comes with the Virtuoso extras listed above, confirmed in writing.

Do I pay you or the hotel?

You pay the hotel directly. We confirm availability and the rate, attach the Virtuoso amenities in writing and hold the room. There is no fee from us.

Eden Rock or
Le Toiny?

Same island. Different pace.

Eden Rock – St Barths

Hotel Le Toiny

The rock in Saint-Jean.

A villa suite and a pool.

Small, private, close to the airport.

Same rate. More included.

Which one we’d book.

Questions, answered.

Tell us your dates. You’ll hear back in minutes.

Eden Rock orLe Toiny?

Same island. Different pace.

Eden Rock – St Barths

Hotel Le Toiny

The rock in Saint-Jean.

A villa suite and a pool.

Small, private, close to the airport.

Same rate. More included.

Which one we’d book.

Questions, answered.

Tell us your dates. You’ll hear back in minutes.

Eden Rock or
Le Toiny?